Scotland’s World Cup campaign has been thrown into another wave of debate after Steve Clarke revealed his possible starting XI for the crucial 2026 FIFA World Cup clash against Morocco — with one Celtic star’s situation leaving supporters asking serious questions.
The decision has sparked a heated reaction among fans, with some questioning whether club form is being overlooked on the biggest stage of all.
With Scotland preparing for a huge Group C encounter against Morocco, every selection decision carries enormous pressure. The Tartan Army arrived at the tournament with hopes of making history, but Clarke knows every mistake could prove costly in a group that also includes football giants Brazil.
After Scotland’s narrow victory over Haiti in their opening fixture, attention quickly turned towards team selection. While the result gave the nation a vital three points, some supporters felt the performance exposed areas that needed improvement — and many expected changes against a dangerous Morocco side.
The biggest talking point has surrounded Celtic representation in the squad, particularly the decision involving a Celtic defender who many fans believe deserves a bigger role.
Supporters have questioned whether certain players are being judged fairly, with some suggesting that reputations and established international partnerships could be influencing Clarke’s choices.
The debate intensified after the expected XI for the Morocco clash began circulating.
A possible Scotland starting lineup for the match:
Possible Scotland XI vs Morocco (2026 FIFA World Cup)
Goalkeeper:
Angus Gunn
Defence:
Anthony Ralston
Jack Hendry
Grant Hanley
Andy Robertson
Midfield:
Billy Gilmour
Scott McTominay
John McGinn
Lewis Ferguson
Attack:
Che Adams
Lyndon Dykes
However, the biggest question remains whether Celtic’s Kieran Tierney can force his way into the starting lineup.
Tierney, who has previously been one of Scotland’s most important defenders, remains highly regarded by supporters. His ability to play in a back three, provide defensive stability, and contribute going forward has made many fans believe he should be among the first names on the team sheet.
Some Celtic supporters have argued that leaving him out would be a major mistake, especially against Morocco’s pace and attacking quality.
“How can a player of his quality sit on the bench in a World Cup match?” one frustrated supporter questioned online.
Others have defended Clarke’s approach, insisting that tournament football requires tactical decisions rather than selecting players based purely on club reputation.
Scotland’s manager faces one of the toughest challenges of his international career. The pressure of a World Cup means every decision will be analysed, every substitution will be questioned, and every omission will become a talking point.
The Morocco match represents a completely different test from the opening game against Haiti. Morocco, known for their defensive organisation, technical ability, and counter-attacking threat, will demand more from Scotland both defensively and creatively.
That could open the door for Tierney or other players currently pushing for a starting role.
A more defensive approach could see Clarke switch formations, potentially moving towards a back three — a system that could benefit Tierney’s qualities.
In that scenario, Scotland could line up differently:
Alternative Scotland XI vs Morocco:
Goalkeeper:
Angus Gunn
Defenders:
Kieran Tierney
Jack Hendry
Grant Hanley
Andy Robertson
Midfield:
Anthony Ralston
Scott McTominay
Billy Gilmour
John McGinn
Forwards:
Che Adams
Lyndon Dykes
The selection debate highlights the fine margins involved at a World Cup. One player starting or being left out can completely change the mood around a national team.
For Celtic fans, the frustration comes from believing their players have earned their opportunity. Celtic has historically provided Scotland with important international figures, and supporters feel their representatives should be trusted when the pressure is highest.
Meanwhile, Clarke will know that results are the only thing that ultimately matter.
If Scotland defeat Morocco, questions over selection may quickly disappear. But if the team struggles, the debate over who should have started will become even louder.
The clash with Morocco is not just another group game — it could define Scotland’s World Cup journey.
And as fans wait for the official team announcement, one question continues to dominate the conversation:
Was Steve Clarke’s decision tactical… or have some players been overlooked?
The answer will be revealed when Scotland step onto the pitch in their biggest match of the tournament so far.
