CELTIC FANS NAME MANAGERS THEY WANT TO REPLACE MARTIN O’NEILL AFTER BENFICA THRASHING
Neil Lennon emerges as a leading contender in the reported betting market, while David Moyes is also attracting attention as frustrated Celtic supporters demand answers following a painful 4–1 defeat in Lisbon.
Celtic are facing renewed questions about their managerial future following their reported 4–1 Europa League defeat against Benfica. The heavy loss has intensified frustration among supporters, with questions being asked about Martin O’Neill’s tactics, team selection and ability to turn the situation around.
The defeat was particularly damaging because Celtic reportedly conceded three goals inside the opening 36 minutes, leaving O’Neill with a difficult task before the match had reached half-time. Although the veteran manager reportedly found encouragement in aspects of his team’s second-half performance, sections of the support were unconvinced.
Attention has now turned towards potential replacements, with former Celtic manager Neil Lennon reportedly emerging as a leading contender in the betting market. Other names linked with the discussion include Shaun Maloney, Scott Brown, Robbie Keane and David Moyes.
However, the betting market and supporters’ opinions are not the same as an official appointment process. Celtic’s immediate priority remains addressing their disappointing performances, while speculation about O’Neill’s future continues to generate debate.
The Benfica Defeat Leaves Celtic Supporters Furious
Celtic’s reported 4–1 defeat against Benfica in Lisbon was a difficult evening for the Scottish side, with the early goals leaving them struggling to recover.
According to the supplied report, O’Neill’s team conceded three times within the first 36 minutes. Falling so far behind so early placed Celtic under enormous pressure and forced them to chase a game against formidable opposition.
For supporters travelling to Portugal or watching from home, the result represented a frustrating setback in a competition where every point can prove important.
The criticism has extended beyond the scoreline, with questions about Celtic’s tactical organisation and the timing of substitutions becoming part of the conversation.
One supporter reportedly argued that O’Neill lacked a clear tactical approach and made changes too late. Another suggested that Benfica were comfortable during the second half despite Celtic’s attempts to respond.
Such reactions reflect the disappointment that can follow a heavy European defeat, particularly when supporters believe their team should be performing better.
Nevertheless, one result does not automatically determine a manager’s future. Celtic’s decision-makers must consider the broader performance of the team, the available squad and whether the current coaching staff can address the problems exposed in Lisbon.
Neil Lennon Emerges as a Leading Name in the Discussion
Neil Lennon has reportedly become a prominent name in the conversation about who could replace O’Neill.
The former Celtic manager has a long association with the club and understands the expectations that come with managing at Parkhead. His previous spells in charge mean that any potential return would inevitably attract strong reactions from supporters.
According to the supplied report, bookmakers have placed Lennon at even-money odds to return for a third spell as Celtic manager.
Those odds suggest that his name is prominent in the reported market, but they do not establish that Celtic have approached him or that an appointment is imminent.
Lennon’s previous experience at Celtic would be an obvious talking point if the club considered another managerial change. Familiarity with the club’s culture, expectations and domestic rivals could be viewed as advantages.
However, a potential return would also invite questions about whether revisiting a former manager is the right solution to the club’s current problems.
Supporters are divided on that question. Some might welcome a familiar figure who understands the demands of the job, while others believe Celtic should explore a different direction.
One supporter reportedly described the prospect of appointing Lennon for a third time as a major mistake.
That disagreement illustrates the challenge facing any club considering a high-profile managerial appointment: popularity, familiarity and experience do not guarantee success.
Shaun Maloney and Scott Brown Among the Other Contenders
Lennon is not the only name mentioned in the reported betting market.
Shaun Maloney is listed at 3/1, placing him among the leading alternatives. As a member of O’Neill’s coaching setup, Maloney would offer familiarity with the current squad and the club’s immediate circumstances.
An appointment from within the existing staff could provide continuity, although it would also raise questions about whether a fresh approach would be necessary following the disappointing European result.
Scott Brown is reportedly priced at 6/1. The former Celtic captain remains closely associated with the club because of his playing career and leadership during a successful period in its history.
His connection with Celtic would make any managerial link an interesting talking point, but the transition from respected player to manager involves different responsibilities and challenges.
Robbie Keane is another reported contender, with odds of 8/1. His managerial experience outside Scotland has also contributed to discussion about whether he could become an option for a club seeking a new direction.
Other names in the supplied list include Steve Clarke at 10/1, Alex Neil at 12/1, Thomas Frank and Sean Dyche at 20/1, and Roy Keane at 100/1.
These figures represent reported betting prices rather than confirmed club targets. They can change as circumstances develop and should not be interpreted as proof that Celtic are negotiating with any particular candidate.
David Moyes Could Represent a Different Direction
While Lennon is reportedly prominent in the betting market, David Moyes has emerged as another name attracting attention.
The supplied report, citing GiveMeSport, states that Moyes is admired by Celtic. It also suggests that uncertainty surrounding his future at Everton could make him a potential candidate if Celtic decide to change managers.
Moyes would bring extensive experience from English football and a background in European competition.
His work with West Ham United culminated in winning the UEFA Europa Conference League in 2023, demonstrating his ability to guide a team through a European campaign and deliver silverware.
That achievement would be relevant to Celtic if the club wanted a manager with experience of competing across domestic and continental competitions.
As a Scottish manager, Moyes would also understand the football culture surrounding Celtic and the expectations attached to one of the country’s most prominent clubs.
However, the prospect of managing Celtic would represent a substantial decision. Any move would depend on the circumstances of his existing position, his own ambitions and whether Celtic were prepared to pursue him.
His reported connection to the vacancy should therefore be treated as speculation rather than confirmation of an impending appointment.
Is Martin O’Neill Really Facing the Sack?
Despite the growing discussion about potential replacements, the supplied report indicates that Celtic have not made an immediate decision to remove O’Neill.
According to the account attributed to Football Insider, the club’s board continues to back the veteran manager, although concerns remain about the team’s recent performances.
The report also suggests that Celtic have not completely ruled out a departure if results continue to deteriorate.
That leaves O’Neill in a difficult position. Continued poor performances could intensify pressure from supporters, while improved results would give him an opportunity to restore confidence.
For a manager at a club of Celtic’s stature, expectations are demanding. Supporters want domestic success, competitive European performances and a team capable of responding positively after setbacks.
The Benfica defeat has increased scrutiny, but the next matches could be important in determining the direction of the debate.
Celtic Must Decide What Comes Next
Celtic’s reported defeat in Lisbon has placed O’Neill’s position under renewed scrutiny and fuelled speculation about possible successors.
Lennon is reportedly prominent in the betting market, while Maloney, Brown and Keane feature among the other names being discussed. Moyes offers a different possibility, bringing extensive managerial experience and a European trophy to his record.
Ultimately, the most important question is not simply which candidate attracts the most attention. It is whether Celtic believe a managerial change is necessary and which appointment would best address the team’s problems.
For now, supporters remain divided, speculation continues and O’Neill faces pressure to deliver improved performances.
Should Celtic bring Neil Lennon back for a third spell, pursue David Moyes, or give Martin O’Neill more time to turn things around? Share your thoughts in the comments below!